logo Monday through Friday: 8am to 5pm ct.
Saturday: 8am to 4pm ct.

Create Account or Contact Us
Skip Navigation Links
 
Enter E-Mail:
Enter Password:

Forget Password?

What Scotsman Buys

Coin Buying Basics
Click Here


Directions to Scotsman

Precious Metals

Scotsman Jewelry

Join Scotsman on Facebook

archives

The Silver Dollar and Rare Coin Expo

joinouremaillist
Name:
Email:
The Collectors' Auction - 2014
< Previous  Lot 26  Next >
Choose Category:
Search Category:
Go to Lot #


Please Note: A 15% Buyers' Premium is added to the hammer price of all lots in this sale.

(About The Images)
1899 $5 VF. 1899 $5 VF.
Lot Title: 1899 $5 VF.
Description: Fr# 271. Premium VF quality includes sizzling paper brilliance and decent centering, although a crease right down the center precludes XF consideration. Nice color for this Lyons/Roberts signature combination.

This lot may contain an item not certified by ANACS, PCGS, or NGC. While Scotsman Auction Co. is typically conservative in our descriptions of items not certified by one of these companies, we cannot guarantee our grading estimation will match their grade. We highly recommend that collectors seeking items certified by a third-party grading service only bid on items that have already been certified. No lot can be returned because of a variance in judgment with regards to grade.

Low Estimate: $850.00
High Estimate: $1,000.00
Lot Status: Bidding has been closed for this lot.
Hammered Price: $675.00
Price Realized: -
1899 $5 VF.
1899 $5 VF.

Price history for items of the same classification:
Lot #AuctionCurrent Bid or Hammer PriceDescription
45The Collectors' Auction 2013 on 10/18/2013$680.00
Two 1899 $5 VG.
New World Estate. Fr# 231. Strict, honest wear -p/aces these into only the VG to Fine range. Ever-popular Black Chief notes that should prove highly approachable to any budget in this two note lot.
46The Collectors' Auction 2013 on 10/18/2013$350.00
1899 $5 F.
New World Estate. Fr# 275. A popular and relatively affordable Chief note with slightly better Napier-McClung signatures. Heavily worn but with vintage appeal.
47The Collectors' Auction 2013 on 10/18/2013$575.00
1899 $5 VF.
New World Estate. Fr# 277. Pleasant for the VF grade with no evidence of tampering or conservation. Just a nice, humble original Chief.
48The Collectors' Auction 2013 on 10/18/2013$850.00
1899 $5 XF.
Fr# 277. Slightly better Friedberg number with Parker-Burke signatures. Lightly pressed and therefore faces up like an AU.
40The Midwest Summer Sale on 07/26/2013$800.00
1899 $5.00. VF.
Fr# 275. The better signature pairing of Napier/McClung will add interest to this already-appealing Chief. Bright original paper and excellent margins make the note irresistible.
152The Collectors' Auction 2012 on 10/05/2012$525.00
1899 $5.00 PCGS VF-35/UR corner rebuilt.
Fr# 278. Cover up the PCGS grade and it would be easy to guess XF+. However, you may cut the price in half because the upper right corner has been previously sliced off and subsequently restored by...
153The Collectors' Auction 2012 on 10/05/2012$1,600.00
1899 $5.00. XF.
Fr# 280. XF at least, with considerable brightness remaining across most of this wavy note. The extreme edges show signs of yellowing consistent with a nice, original Chief.
154The Collectors' Auction 2012 on 10/05/2012$1,325.00
1899 $5.00 PMG XF-45.
Fr# 281. From within the PMG holder, this looks exactly like any other AU note, with blazing white paper and razor sharp edges. A terrific chief at only the XF level.
155The Collectors' Auction 2012 on 10/05/2012$1,300.00
1899 $5.00. PMG AU-50/trimmed.
Fr# 281. Extremely tight margins at top and bottom, but who really cares when an AU note looks this nice? Superior paper and ink look new at first glance.
157The Midwest Summer Sale 2012 on 07/27/2012$825.00
1899 $5.00. XF.
Fr# 280. Affordable grade for this nice, high quality Chief. Not far at all from AU, with no creases and only modest bends in the center of the paper.
158The Midwest Summer Sale 2012 on 07/27/2012$1,650.00
1899 $5.00. AU.
Fr# 281. Fantastic for the AU level, most bidders will see that as UNC at first, and even second inspection. Exceptionally bright with vibrant design elements and clean, sharp edges.
43The Collectors' Auction 2011 on 10/21/2011$825.00
1899 $5.00. VF.
Fr. 281. Beautiful note that should lie in the upper VF grade range, as it looks as nice as some AU examples. Lightly pressed, the internal folds are a little more evident from the back. Nice...
44The Collectors' Auction 2011 on 10/21/2011$1,200.00
1899 $5.00. PCGS XF-45.
Fr. 277. Immensely attractive and easily knocking on the door of an AU grade. The lower left corner was once-folded, but there is nothing else even remotely negative about the gorgeous appearance.
45The Collectors' Auction 2011 on 10/21/2011$4,200.00
1899 $5.00. CHCU.
Fr. 275. Drop-dead irresistible, with great embossing and fabulous color. The front is tight at top and bottom, or else this might be a fully gem note.
68The Midwest Summer Sale 2011 on 07/29/2011$725.00
1899 $5.00. VF.
Fr. 280. Always popular, this Chief note is in the perfect grade for collectors - not too high (i.e. expensive), but well preserved enough to provide all the
56The Midwest Summer Sale 2010 on 07/23/2010$450.00
1899 $5.00 VG, and an 1899 $1 VF.
Fr# 236 and 271. The "black eagle" is a gorgeous, original note in VF that not been messed with, nor even pressed. It's companion "chief" note features the Lyons/Roberts signature combination and is...
57The Midwest Summer Sale 2010 on 07/23/2010$1,020.00
1899 $5.00 Mule. PMG XF-40 EPQ.
Fr# 280. Gorgeous, bright note with absolutely no problems for the XF grade. Edges are sharp with little wear at the corners and subtle staining noticeable along the front bottom edge.
58The Midwest Summer Sale 2010 on 07/23/2010$1,450.00
1899 $5.00. AU.
Fr# 278. Bright and simply delightful "Chief" for just the AU grade. As one of the only American Indians depicted on U.S. paper currency, the picture as engraved on the note caused consternation...
45The Midwest Summer Sale on 07/24/2009$675.00
1899 $5.00. VF.
Fr-279. Lightly toned and fully original 1899 chief note. An affordable note for type purposes.
46The Midwest Summer Sale on 07/24/2009$650.00
1899 $5.00. VF.
Fr-279. Barely toned with minor creases and a couple of fingerprints on the front. Original VF or better quality.
47The Midwest Summer Sale on 07/24/2009$390.00
1899 $5.00. PCGS Apparent VF-25, small edge tear.
Fr-273. An outstanding AU appearance is not marred by any internal folds or problems, but PCGS notes "small edge tear at top center". Probably a rather drastic 25 point downgrade, though, as this is...
48The Midwest Summer Sale on 07/24/2009$1,700.00
1899 $5.00. AU.
Fr-271. Highly attractive AU or better note that looks fully CU except that the upper left corner was lightly folded. Radiant paper with vivid ink and an excellent type note.
142The Midwest Winter Sale 2009 on 02/13/2009$825.00
1899 $5.00. VF.
Fr-1899. Bright, crisp, and colorful enough to qualify as an XF, but just a fold or two under that grade. Nicely margined, and original. Great type note.
143The Midwest Winter Sale 2009 on 02/13/2009$925.00
1899 $5.00. XF.
Fr-278. Three light folds, but otherwise showing many of the qualities of a higher-graded note. Great dark-blue seal and crisp white paper. Better Tehee/Burke signatures.
144The Midwest Winter Sale 2009 on 02/13/2009$1,800.00
1899 $5.00. PMG AU-55.
Fr-274. Only a faint center fold prevents this attractive Oncpapa Chief from grading Unc. Wonderfully bright and with fantastic color.
145The Midwest Winter Sale 2009 on 02/13/2009$2,400.00
1899 $5.00. C.G.C GemCU-65.
Fr-272. CGC has understandably given this note a "gem uncirculated' (65) grade, and there is no doubt that this is a marvelous note. Edges are very sharp, with only the upper left corner being not...
117The Midwest Winter Sale 2008 on 02/08/2008$650.00
Three Large Size Silver Certificates.
Fr-274 $5 Chief Fine, Fr-258 $2 VG, and Fr-238 $1 VF. Great group of three large size silver certificate type notes, with the highlight being a popular Chief note. They are all pleasing examples for...
125The Midwest Winter Sale 2008 on 02/08/2008$2,200.00
1899 $5.00. CU.
Fr-278. The paper is wavy in areas, and there are a couple of creases around the bottom-left third of the back. However, no true folds are present, so most would likely agree it technically...
114The Collectors' Auction 2007 on 10/19/2007$950.00
1899 $5.00. XF.
Fr-280. Popular Chief type that is nice and white on the front with rich ink. Though not quite as white on the back, the ink is just as rich. Very crisp, but feels lightly flattened. Elliott/White...
160The Midwest Summer Sale 2007 on 07/27/2007$380.00
1899 $5.00. VG.
Fr-278. A Teehee/Burke signature combination example of a popular type. Heavily circulated, but probably conservatively graded as the paper in not torn, and there are no pinholes.
161The Midwest Summer Sale 2007 on 07/27/2007$475.00
1899 $5.00. F+.
Fr-281. Solid for the grade F+, and some viewers will likely determine that the VF grade is more appropriate. The paper is mostly white and is overlaid with mostly preserved printing.
162The Midwest Summer Sale 2007 on 07/27/2007$600.00
1899 $5.00. F.
Fr-280. An original example of a somewhat more common Elliot/White type. A minor margin tear and pinhole are seen on the top margin, but otherwise this is a commendable example of the grade.
163The Midwest Summer Sale 2007 on 07/27/2007$2,400.00
1899 $5.00 Star. VF.
Fr-258*. Only nine Parker - Burke star notes are currently known. This is a solid VF with a decent layout and no tears or pinholes. The paper remains crisp for the grade.
164The Midwest Summer Sale 2007 on 07/27/2007$1,300.00
1899 $5.00. XF.
Fr-278. Looks like an Uncirculated note at first sight as the folds are not seen initially and the color is so vibrant. Only when closely viewed will three light folds be seen. Possibly pressed at...
165The Midwest Summer Sale 2007 on 07/27/2007$1,700.00
1899 $5.00. AU.
Fr-280. A bright Chief Silver Certificate with a strong ink presence. The top margin is cut a tad tight, but not into the design. Great paper preservation and crispness.
169The Midwest Winter Sale 2007 on 02/09/2007$1,000.00
1899 $5.00. XF.
Fr-271. Crisp and original enough to grade higher, and the color is definitely nice enough, but three vertical folds and an erased pencil marking only allow for the XF grade. Scarce Lyons - Roberts...
170The Midwest Winter Sale 2007 on 02/09/2007$3,900.00
1899 $5.00. GemCU.
Fr-277. Gorgeous Gem CU Chief note that looks completely ageless. Everything from the color, to the layout, to the freshness are all superb. If ever there were a note for which a collector should...
152The Collector's Auction on 10/20/2006$1,300.00
1899 $5.00. XF.
Fr-280. Rich color and bright white paper make this note appear like an AU Chief example. However, it has evidently been lightly pressed as the folds that make it an XF are somewhat hidden. The...
153The Collector's Auction on 10/20/2006$1,000.00
1899 $5.00. XF.
Fr-278. A lovely Oncpapa Chief that has been lightly pressed but has retained nice color and margins. The folds are light, and the paper is free from pinholes.
154The Collector's Auction on 10/20/2006$1,300.00
1899 $5.00. AU.
Fr-278. Wonderfully bright Chief note with fantastic color. Only a very minor center fold prevents this better signature variety from grading Unc. Nice margins.
150The Midwest Summer Sale 2006 on 07/21/2006$1,050.00
1899 $5.00. XF.
Fr-280. Some may consider this note, at the very least, an XF+, or possibly even an AU, but a couple of russet toning areas on the reverse probably will only allow for the XF grade. It is original...
151The Midwest Summer Sale 2006 on 07/21/2006$2,600.00
1899 $5.00. CHCU.
Fr-280. An excellent note with fantastic margins and lovely color. The paper is bright, the corners are sharp corners, and the appeal is strong. If only a top notch Oncpapa example is acceptable to...

Scotsman Coin and Jewelry, Inc.
11262 Olive Boulevard
St. Louis, MO 63141
314-692-2646
Business Hours: Monday through Friday from 8a to 5p ct, and Saturday from 8a to 4p ct, closed Sunday.
©Copyright 2015  Scotsman Coin and Jewelry Inc. All Rights Reserved
For more information feel free to Contact Us
New Server